Restalrig Road South · Ward 14 Craigentinny/Duddingston · evidence as of 20 Nov 2026

Smokey Brae: how a ready scheme stalled

Consulted on in spring 2022, Smokey Brae was due to start traffic orders in 2023/24 and be delivered in 2024/25. Since then its scope has grown to take in Marionville Road and Restalrig and Marionville Avenues, its promised dates have moved back twice, and in November 2026 the traffic orders are still not advertised.

Orders promised: 2023/24 → 2025/26 → "within the next year" Delivery promised: 2024/25 → 2026/27 2022 consultation: 50% for, 49% against

Promises against progress

The top row shows each date the council promised, placed at the time it said it. Below that is what actually happened, lane by lane. Select any date or dot to see the source.

Date promised Promise missed Moved forward Set back Context

Why it has stalled

  1. The scope grew, and the clock restarted.In January 2023 the council promised traffic mitigation on Marionville and Restalrig Avenues. By January 2025 officers had added Marionville Road and made the traffic orders wait for a new consultation. The committee noted this; it never voted on it.Jan 2023 · Jan 2025 · Nov 2026
  2. It lost its home in the Meadowbank regeneration.Moved into the council-wide active travel programme, it now competes for capital. It ranked mid-table in May 2025, and only design funding was sought for 2025/26.Jan 2025 · May 2025 · Sep 2025
  3. The design went backwards.Listed at Technical Design in September 2025, it is back at Developed Design in November 2026, now as "Smokey Brae and Marionville".Sep 2025 · Nov 2026
  4. The one-way section is a political flashpoint.Two amendments to rethink or pause it failed, both led by a Ward 14 councillor. The 50/49 consultation split gives opponents an argument.Jan 2025 · May 2025
  5. It depends on a fire station decision.The design outside Marionville Fire Station will change if the fire service moves its appliances, and that decision has been postponed repeatedly through 2026.Nov 2025 · Jul 2026

Questions to put to the council

  1. Who decided to expand the scope to Marionville Road and the full length of Restalrig and Marionville Avenues, and when?
  2. Why is the scheme shown back at Developed Design in November 2026?
  3. Can the Smokey Brae traffic orders be advertised on their own, ahead of the wider changes?
  4. Is the Marionville Fire Station decision holding up the orders?
  5. Is construction funding allocated for 2026/27, the year the project page still promises delivery?

Sources

Compiled from City of Edinburgh Council committee papers (Transport and Environment Committee, all meetings Jan 2022 – Nov 2026), the council's project pages, the 2022 consultation report, and community council minutes. The project page carries no date; its promises are plotted at the date it was read. Where a cause is inferred rather than stated, it is marked as such in the detail.